If your boiler is getting old, or you're renovating, you'll probably be weighing up two options: a new gas boiler (often a combi) or an air source heat pump. Both can heat a home well. The right choice depends on your property, your budget and how you use heating and hot water.
We install both boilers and heat pumps across London, from Barnet and North London outwards, so this guide sets out the trade-offs as we see them, without the sales pitch.
How each system works
Gas boiler
A gas boiler burns natural gas to heat water, which is pumped round your radiators (or underfloor heating). A combi boiler also heats hot water straight from the mains when you turn on a tap, so there's no hot water cylinder. System and regular boilers store hot water in a cylinder instead.
Boilers run at high flow temperatures, so radiators get hot quickly and the house warms up fast.
Air source heat pump
An air source heat pump takes heat from the outside air and moves it into your heating system, using electricity to run a compressor, much like a fridge working in reverse. Because it moves heat rather than making it by burning fuel, it delivers more heat energy than the electricity it uses.
Heat pumps work best at lower flow temperatures, running steadily for longer. They heat hot water into a stored cylinder, so you'll need room for one. For more detail, see our guide on how a heat pump works in your property.
Heat pump vs gas boiler at a glance
Gas or combi boiler
- Fuel: mains gas, burned at home
- Hot water: on demand (combi) or from a cylinder (system/regular)
- Outdoor unit: none, just a flue
- Radiators: usually work as they are
- Insulation: helps, but not essential
- Grant: none
- Servicing: every year, by a Gas Safe registered engineer
Air source heat pump
- Fuel: electricity, nothing burned at home
- Hot water: from a stored cylinder
- Outdoor unit: yes
- Radiators: some may need upsizing
- Insulation: important for good performance
- Grant: Boiler Upgrade Scheme for eligible homes
- Servicing: yearly check recommended
Installation: what to expect
Gas boiler. Swapping an old boiler for a new one is usually a short job, often done in a day or two, especially like-for-like. Moving the boiler, or converting from a regular system to a combi, adds time.
Heat pump. A heat pump installation is a bigger project. It starts with a heat loss survey of every room so the system is sized properly. Some radiators may need upsizing, you'll need space for the outdoor unit and a hot water cylinder, and the job usually takes several days. The upfront cost is normally higher than a boiler swap, although grants can reduce it.
We give fixed quotes after a survey, so the best way to compare is to get both options priced for your home. Get a free quote.
Running costs
There's no single answer here, because running costs depend on:
- Gas and electricity prices (and your tariff, including heat-pump or time-of-use tariffs)
- How well insulated the home is
- How well the system is designed and set up (flow temperature, radiator sizes, controls)
- How you use heating and hot water
A well-designed heat pump in a reasonably insulated home can be competitive with gas. A poorly sized one, or one in a draughty home, can cost more to run. That's why the survey and design stage matters so much.
Grants: the Boiler Upgrade Scheme
In England and Wales, the government's Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) gives a grant towards replacing a fossil-fuel boiler with a heat pump in eligible homes. The installer applies on your behalf and the grant comes off your bill. Amounts and eligibility rules are set by the government and can change, so check the current details on GOV.UK: Apply for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme.
There's no equivalent grant for a new gas boiler.
Space and noise
- Boiler: a combi fits in a kitchen cupboard and needs no cylinder, ideal for flats and smaller homes.
- Heat pump: needs an outdoor spot with good airflow (garden, side return or flat roof) plus indoor space for a cylinder. Modern outdoor units are quiet, but placement still matters for you and your neighbours, and planning rules apply to where they go.
Lifespan and maintenance
Both systems should be serviced every year to stay safe, efficient and within warranty. Gas boilers must only be worked on by a Gas Safe registered engineer. Heat pumps have fewer combustion parts, but still need regular checks of the refrigerant circuit, filters, controls and outdoor unit.
What about oil and LPG boilers?
If you're off the gas grid on oil or LPG, a heat pump is often a strong alternative, and the Boiler Upgrade Scheme covers replacing those boilers too (subject to eligibility).
Which should you choose?
A gas boiler may suit you better if:
- You live in a flat or small home with no outdoor space for a unit
- You want the lowest upfront cost and a quick swap
- The property is hard to insulate and you'd rather not change radiators
A heat pump may suit you better if:
- You have outdoor space and room for a hot water cylinder
- The home is reasonably insulated, or you're renovating anyway
- You want to stop burning fossil fuels at home and can use the Boiler Upgrade Scheme
Many homes could go either way. A survey is the quickest way to find out what works for yours.
Talk to a London heating engineer
Heatmaster London installs and services gas boilers and air source heat pumps across London, including Barnet and North London. If you're not sure which way to go, we'll look at your home and price up the options honestly. Contact us or see our FAQs.